The limitations and dangers of using LinkedIn

• Sunday, September 13th, 2009

Business Card
There are lots of books and courses available on how to use LinkedIn with the standard messages and tools. But those courses tend to produce users who think that if being listed in the software is good using it heavily without further thought is better. I disagree.

  1. In the Twin Cities Metro there are 4K LinkedIn listings with “marketing communications” mentioned, 59K with “sales,” and 31K with “engineer.” 65% social media participants users use to stay in touch with friends, 47% use social media “for work” and but only 26-28% use it for “career search.” # That means you need to develop strategies to be appealing to all kinds of networkers who will find you there and you need a very well written profile and customized communications to rise above the clutter.
  2. The average reader spends 8-10 seconds with a profile. Your full resume does NOT belong in LinkedIn. The correct profile is closer to an executive bio in a corporate website.
  3. LinkedIn should not be viewed as a stand-alone tool especially by those of you who are uncomfortable pairing LinkedIn activities with networking done in-person or by phone. Using LinkedIn exclusively can actually damage your professional image if your best means of reaching out to someone is the pre-written and highly superficial messages available by default in the system. Aim for a small, high quality network of people you can vouch for and whom you can trust to recommend you effectively. Consider that you will be judged by the quality of relationships you exhibit there. When you suddenly need a strong recommendation, a large quantity of poor quality contacts in your network will dilute the credibility of someone who really has considerable knowledge of you, especially if they use the standard messaging and tools to recommend you.
  4. Hide your contacts. You want to manage how, why, and when others are reaching out to your best contacts and clients. The social media are mechanical software tools that encourage use without much thought which may be good as a strategy for the company LinkedIn, but bad as yours. Approximately 1/3 of the requests I receive through electronic social media I consider inappropriate to someone else in the relationship. The sender did not think hard before sending the request because it was easy to do so. If they had to make the same request in person they would have thought about it a lot more carefully. I think it is also happening more because people are in a panic over job security.
  5. Hiring managers prefer people who are currently employed and can buy access to all 40 million names. There are many ways to reach potential hirees without buying a job ad in LinkedIn and most hiring managers are not bothering to. Ads on the 2 big job boards declined 5-44% last year depending on industry.
  6. You are judged in LinkedIn as much by your EQ as by your IQ. An ExecuNet study (12/08) showed:
    • 86% exec recruiters search online for information beyond resume
    • 70% say their opinion of job seeker improves if find positive info on internet
  7. We know that being active and engaged in LinkedIn activities improves your rank in LinkedIn searches:
    • Include a picture
    • Participate in discussion groups and Q+A with others
    • Answer InMail queries from others and pass profiles onwards if and only if you can vouch for the recommendation
    • Give and get recommendations
    • Name corporate, academic awards, boards, associations, biz charities
  8. Remember that what you post in social media is VERY public and available to be scrutinized and commented on by many critics. A recent survey by Career Builder and highlighted in the Wall St Journal stated that 35% of employers report they found content on social media sites that caused them not to hire a candidate. ##
    • Candidate showed poor communication skills – 29%
    • Candidate lied about qualifications – 24 %
    • Candidate shared confidential information from previous employer – 20 %
  9. If you think about the experience of the person searching for a resource in LinkedIn, he/she is confronted with 100-500 profiles (depending on subscription level) with similar titles or search criteria. The first profile the seeker will reach out to will demonstrate:
    • Better accomplishments than their peers
    • Good communication skills, and transparency of skills
    • Candor, warmth, accessibility, and ethics
    • NO Political, racial, religious, marital status, or sexual preference mentions because Hiring Managers will avoid downloading it for fear of an EEO lawsuit

So, invest some time and effort into your LinkedIn strategies. Don’t use the software as your only means of networking. Don’t settle for its default messages. Think about the paradigm of the other people in the LinkedIn network and what they might want from you when they are looking at your profile. LinkedIn has huge potential but can be more damaging than helpful to your career image if used too casually.

#   http://www.pewinternet.org/pdfs/PIP_Adult_social_networking_data_memo_FINAL.pdf
## http://online.wsj.com/article/PR-CO-20090819-902554.html

Share
You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can skip to the end and leave a response. Pinging is currently not allowed.

3 Responses

  1. 1
    Max Swanson 

    These caveats are good for any use of social media. I find the true network sites like Facebook a bit cluttered, but I’m sure all these warnings apply there as well.

  2. 2
    Jane Roth 

    Bottom line-Linkedin has made it easier to find people’s names.
    ….My focus is getting more job orders…..
    I am trying to change industries.
    All recruiters I speak to have this same problem- they need more job orders.
    Companies do not want to pay fees.
    I email people in linked in they do not answer me. Emails are not answered that much either.
    Phone is still the best way.

  3. I’m a president and founder of my own company, so I’m not really looking to enhance my resume, etc. However, I recently found my competitors advertising next to my own profile. I don’t know what anybody else is seeing. For me, and for my situation, I find that building a web profile so that LinkedIn can use me as an advertising beacon is counter productive, so I’m getting out as soon as possible. I hope somebody creates a better solution, such as a web plugin that allows professional networks to be formed without control of LinkedIn, and without all the advertisements. I also worry about exposure of my personal data, that’s why I never went too far to begin with.

Leave a Response